Custom Orders

****BOOKED THROUGH July 5, 2022***

Custom cookies orders start at $54 per a dozen. Fill out the Cookie Order Request form below and I’ll be with you soon about your order!

Current Flavors:

  • Signature Vanilla Bean
  • Chocolate
  • Lemon
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Chocolate Chip

Current Availability

Currently booking for July- September 2022. Please fill out the form below or send me an email at stacy@stirwhiskandroll.com.

*All requests will be responded to as quickly as possible. Please allow 48 hours for response. Please check your spam for an email from stacy@stirwhiskandroll.com if you don’t see a response within 48 hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where do you bake?

All cookies are baked under the Illinois Cottage Laws and Stir Whisk and Roll is reregistered with the City of Chicago according to the state law. I take every step to follow all laws and food safety standards including having my Food Manager Certificate by passing the Food Protection Manager Exam as well as completing training in food allergens and safety. Per state law, I must state:

“The product was produced in a home kitchen not inspected by a health department that may also process common food allergens. If you have safety concerns, contact your local health department.”

How much notice do you need for a custom cookie order?

While this depends on how busy I am, I recommend reaching out at least two weeks before you’d like cookies. I can’t guarantee that I will have availability, but the earlier you reach out, the more likely I will be able to accept your order. During the holidays, I recommend six weeks before your event in order for me to be able to accommodate any requests during this very busy season.

What is your price for custom cookies?

Custom cookies start at $54 per dozen. Depending on the complexity, some orders may cost more. I aim to be very open when we talk about the cost based on each request.

Why do custom cookies cost so much?

To start, I use the best ingredients to bake my cookies so you get the best product, but custom cookies require a lot more than just baking and decorating cookies. Each custom order takes me time to design based on each customer’s request, and often times, I also have to purchase new cookie cutters for custom orders and spend a few hours working out designs.

Do you do rush orders?

Short answer is yes, if possible. While I do recommend at least two weeks notice, I may have some space so feel free to email me and see. Cookie orders have to be at least 3 day before expected deliver/pickup date because it takes 8-12 hours for the icing to dry. Many cookies also require multiple layers of icing, so less than 3 days, it is unlikely I will be able to get you cookies completed. I do charge an extra $10 per dozen for rush order cookies.

Do you deliver?


Yes, I definitely will deliver since my kitchen is a little ways out in the suburbs. If you on the north side Chicago, delivery is free. If you are outside this area, I charge $10 to cover my gas.